Chapter 2- The Payback

You can find Chapter 1 here!

Getting ready to head to the pub for a few drinks had never been so hard. I didn’t used to think that much about what I would wear there but now I felt like I had to impress. Christmas eve night had been so fun, laughing, drinking, and carrying on just like there was no tension, no fighting or bitter history between us.

Usually Niall wouldn’t text me for a few weeks after we have hung out, probably so I wouldn’t get the wrong idea and start assuming he was actually into me. But here we were, only a day later, and he’s telling me to come. I could go through this in my head for hours and just keep turning in circles. Getting nowhere with my thoughts, and staring blankly at my closet, I decided I needed to start with a staple piece of clothing. My black skinny jeans. They made my ass look great, and Niall’s always loved them. They are my “get-Niall-horny” pants.

I chuckle thinking about the amount of times he’s ripped these off of me. How many times they’ve been thrown in his dorm room, in his parents’ basement, in my bedroom, on the floor of his car… God, our sex adventures were awesome. I just wish I hadn’t fallen for the kid that I couldn’t escape thanks to our families. Now that Niall’s career had taken off, his band was traveling more and more often. It seemed longer each time when he was away and I was scared that soon enough he would never be back. I had to take advantage of the opportunities while he was here.

Diving back in my closet I decide to go for simplicity. Guys always seem to go for jeans and a v-neck. I find a soft, tight, grey v-neck tee with lace cutouts on the back. When I wear my black bra under this it looks awesome. I grab my Frye engineer boots and throw them on over my skinnies. I’ve never been a heels kinda girl, and my motto has always been that I’d rather look short than look like I can’t walk.

As much as I keep telling myself that tonight is just going to be a fun time and I shouldn’t have any expectations, the excitement works its way into my system and I can’t help but feel hope that I finally won’t be the one doing the chasing.

As I got in my car to drive to the bar, I picked up my daydreaming where I left off this morning…

When we got back to the football field Ashling walked with me over to our parents. “Look who I found!” I said presenting Ashling like she was a game-show prize. She spun around in circle for me. Our moms laughed at us and Ashling ran over to tell her mom about what she picked up shopping.

My dad came over to talk to Niall and I about getting the alcohol out of the car. “Just, ya know, carry it over discreetly… put it behind the mom’s bleachers… gotta get back to the sidelines, thanks you two!”

We quickly transported the alcohol from the car back to the field, me carrying two lighter cases that had the liquor and mixers and Niall not-so-discreetly hauling the cases that were wrapped in blankets. While we were gone, the first game had wrapped up but they had another one right after so we still had a few good hours to kill.

Once we dropped off the stash, Niall shouted “Mom! We’re going to check out who is at community!” “Okay, see ya guys!” she shouted back. Niall raised both eyebrows at me and started walking back in the direction of the car. Was he seriously thinking about making me pay him back here? I started to get nervous… Last time was so spur-of-the-moment and looking back I don’t know how I even came off as smooth as I did. Now that I was having time to think about what was going to happen, I was freaking out. Mainly because I thought I would do something wrong, he wouldn’t think I was doing it right, or he wouldn’t like it.

The parking lot where our car sat was partially blocked by a row of bushes and on the other side of the lot was the community pool. We crossed into the parking lot, now out of view of the football field, and he strolled back towards the end of the lot where his dad’s shiny Range Rover was sitting, tinted windows and all. “Wow, its like he has been planning this forever. This setup couldn’t be more perfect for a midday hookup in a public setting,” I thought.

He opened the back car door and let me slide in the seat first. Sitting down next to me and closing the door, he reached both hands into the pockets of his shorts. He pulled out two beer cans and flashed me the smile that melts my insides. “I snuck two out of the case for us, enjoy,” he said tossing me the other can. I really didn’t like beer, I had only had it a few times but the taste hadn’t quite grown on me yet. But lets be honest, I needed something to break the tension on my side and alcohol was a sure bet.

“Now before my sister so rudely interrupted us, I believe we were in the middle of something.” Niall said, sliding closer to me and taking a long gulp from his can.

“Ha, so we’re just jumping right in are we?” I thought. Even though his voice and eyes and hands made me weak I was determined not to let it show. I wasn’t just one of those sluts he hooks up with and I was going to make sure he knew it. “Oh really Ni? Didn’t seem like the middle to me, but it was a great end, I’ll give ya that,” and I winked and patted his chest.

“Honey you have a lot to learn about give and take, because that’s just not how it works. Apparently no ones taught you that, but I could.” He put his elbow up on the back of the car seat. The closeness of his actions made me squirm a little and I took a sip of my beer, not knowing how to respond.

Niall took another sip out of his beer. God, he even looked fuckin’ sexy doing that. He was just a natural at this. “You see,” he continued, “I gave you something and now you owe me something back. Although I have to admit I wouldn’t mind getting a better taste of you, if you know what I mean.” He looked from my face and down my body, sending shivers through my spine.

I did know what he meant, but the thought kind of terrified me. It was hard enough to do the flirty banter. But to be so exposed in front of Niall, who was like family… I felt my cheeks flush thinking about it. I’m sure he did this with girls all the time though, especially when he was on the road. I think what bothered me was that he was looking at me as if I was just another one of those girls, not the one he’s grown up with.

I gave a nervous laugh and started saying “I just-” But Niall cut me off, “C’mon babe, you can’t say no to this face, can ya?” As he leaned his head into my face and looked up from under his eyelashes, batting his eyes a bit. I laughed at how ridiculous and cute he looked. He brought his hand up to cradle my cheek and gently touched his lips with mine.

At the moment of contact I felt my inhibitions slipping away. His touch sent electricity through my veins and I sighed as his lips worked perfectly with mine. He nibbled at my bottom lip then prodded my mouth open with his tongue. I blindly found a cup holder to shove my beer in and reached up to wind my arms around his neck.

Niall’s hand roughly worked his way up my dress, attempting to find its way into my bra. He grabbed my one breast and took my nipple in between his two fingers, pinching it slightly. He became frustrated at being constrained and swiftly removed his hand to push my dress straps off my shoulders and snap my bra off all in the matter of seconds.

His eyes immediately were drawn to my chest. He squeezed both of my breasts and brought his mouth to my right nipple, just hovering above it so I could feel his hot breath against my sensitive skin. His tongue reached out and flicked my nipple before swirling in circles around it. I let out a soft moan making him go in for the plunge. He sucked and nipped at me as I felt the tension growing deep in my stomach, groans constantly escaping from my mouth. He repeated the same torture on my other breast, leaving my right one damp and rock hard.

Finally when I thought I couldn’t take anymore, I brought my hands to his cheeks and he immediately responded by surfacing and looking me straight in the eyes. “You’re right babe, I almost forgot this time was supposed to be all about me,” he said with a sly look on his face. That was not at all what I was thinking. I just needed something filling me up and fucking me senseless before the burning between my legs actually lit me on fire. I really just wanted to feel what he made me feel back in that garage again. I was willing to beg at this point.

He leaned back and started undoing his shorts. Pulling them and his boxers down in one swift motion, his erection bounced back up against his stomach. The size of it surprised me and I couldn’t take my eyes off of it. Niall laughed at my reaction, but I still couldn’t help it. He grabbed my wrist and pulled me on top of him as he leaned against the car door. Feeling his erection pressed against me through only the thin fabric of my sundress made me feel so desperate to have something inside of me. My control was running away and I kept trying to remind myself to not take it that far. I was not going to be one of his sluts. I wanted to be his… but not like one of them.

Niall reached down to my panties and rubbed me for a few seconds before pushing them away and shoving a finger inside me. “Ohh my god..” I moaned involuntarily. This was exactly what I wanted. This was the amazing shit he did earlier this afternoon. I could do this everyday for the rest of my life. He worked my clit with his thumb and kept pumping his fingers in and out. I let my hand travel down over his abs until I reached his cock and grabbed onto it, making him gasp. I leaned down to his lips and kissed him forcefully as he still worked inside of me, now sending me close to the edge. I pumped up and down on his shaft and I could feel the precum at the tip. I took my thumb and circled around, spreading out the wetness.

Niall slid further down on the seat, taking me with him. He grabbed my one leg saying, “flip around.” He was able to throw me around pretty easily before I realized what he was doing. I was now almost facing backward, his dick pointed straight at my face, and he was just about to bring my leg on the other side of his face, so he was inches from my wetness.

That’s when I reached my breaking point. It was too much. Too soon. Too close. He felt me hesitate and slightly jerked my leg in an attempt to close myself up, “Ni, I can’t.. I just, I don’t kno-”

“Are you fuckin serious?” He said flipping my leg back towards the car floor rather harshly. He was irritated. He snorted, “Fine babe, but I was just trying to do you a favor too while I get mine.”

At this point I was kneeling on the car floor between the front and back seats. He sat back against the seat, put his hands on my face, pulling me toward him. He planted one soft kiss on my lips and my irritation with him disappeared. He pulled my face away, piercing me with his crystal blue eyes, scoffed and whispered, “but I’ll just sit back and relax while you get to work” as his eyes flicked from mine, down to his cock, and then back up. I hated the fact that it was kind of a turn on when he was a dick like this. But I’m not going to lie, I wanted to suck him off.

I looked down and took him in my hand like I had before, pumping up and down a few times before rubbing the tip with my thumb. I lowered my face and used my tongue to lick up the precum and swirl it around his head. “Enough with the teasing already,” he breathed lifting his hips slightly off the seat.

I surrounded his tip with my lips completely and took as much of him in as I could until he hit the back of my throat. Bobbing up and down, I licked from base to tip, and swirled around the top until plunging back down. With each stroke I got a little deeper, sliding up and down with a regular rhythm. I could feel Niall losing his calmness as he tangled his fingers in my hair. “Shit! C’mon you can take a little more!” he grunted, and with that he bucked his hips up, holding onto my hair to push my head further down on his cock. I gagged but fought the uncomfortable urge as the tears formed in the corners of my eyes. His praise kept me going as he yelled out “Fuck! That’s fuckin amazing! Ohh!,” bucking more and more each time. Only a few more thrusts and Niall grunted out “Fuck I’m gonna come!” In a few seconds he emptied his load and it shot deep into my mouth, running down the back of my throat, I kept going as he rode out his orgasm.

When he finished, his hips returned to the seat and he placed two fingers under my chin, lifting it upward. “Bottoms up,” he winked at me as I swallowed. What a fucking smartass. Niall pulled his pants back on and ran the back of his hand across his forehead, wiping away the beads of sweat that had formed there. I was sitting back up on the seat, adjusting my dress, when he leaned over and gave me a peck on the cheek. “I think I’d say we’re even now. I’m gonna get back to watch the game. Cya babe.” He winked as he climbed out of the car.

That son of a bitch! He was just going to leave me here, horny as hell, in the back of his father’s car? He wasn’t even going to walk out with me? Or even talk? Tears began to form in my eyes as I thought about the promise I made to myself earlier. I thought I wasn’t going to be one of them, but I was. I had always known why all those girls fling themselves at him, but now I also knew why they kept coming back for more even when he treated them like this. Even now, as upset as I was, I wanted him again. I wanted to prove something. That I could make him like me as more than just a friend and a person to fuck. So I decided that, since I knew I wasn’t going to escape him, at least I was going to make sure I got something out of it next time.

God, I was so naive then. I shake my head thinking about my stupid past self as I walk into the bar. Niall couldn’t be changed then… but maybe tonight, years later, he could be? I can’t wait to see what tonight has to bring. With that thought, my phone buzzes and I see Nialler on the screen… “I’ve got a surprise waiting for you when you get here… ;)”

I smile to myself thinking, “tonight’s either going to be really bad or really good.”

Ah omg The Chase Chapter 2!! This was harder to write but mainly because I didn’t know where to stop. Next part is (in my opinion) going to be great so I can’t wait to start it. Please leave comments & feedback in my ask!! If you like it, please reblog!! Thanks for reading, I hope you enjoyed!! xx

Edit: Here is the link to Chapter 3!